The Bill will introduce three new offences. An adult misrepresenting their age online to a minor will now face a maximum 3 year jail term.
An adult misrepresenting their age in order to meet a minor will face a five year prison term and an adult misrepresenting their age with the intention of assaulting a minor will face a maximum 8 years prison term.
Quoting the Questions; Probing the Possibilities; Analysing the Answers.
The voice of a left leaning Aussie committed to liberal democratic socialism and pluralism throughout all facets of society.
I am particularly valiant when it comes to issues of rights, justice, and freedom from religion.
Xenophon's head up his own arse!
An Obituary
Today we mourn the passing of a beloved old friend, 'Common Sense', who has been with us for many years. No one knows for sure how old he was, since his birth records were long ago lost in bureaucratic red tape. He will be remembered as having cultivated such valuable lessons as: Knowing when to come in out of the rain; why the early bird gets the worm; Life isn't always fair; and maybe it was my fault.
Common Sense lived by simple, sound financial policies (don't spend more than you can earn) and reliable strategies (adults, not children, are in charge).
His health began to deteriorate rapidly when well-intentioned but overbearing regulations were set in place. Reports of a 6-year-old boy charged with sexual harassment for kissing a classmate; teens suspended from school for using mouth wash after lunch; and a teacher fired for reprimanding an unruly student, only worsened his condition.
Common Sense lost ground when parents attacked teachers for doing the job that they themselves had failed to do in disciplining their unruly children.
It declined even further when schools were required to get parental consent to administer sun lotion or an Aspirin to a student; but could not inform parents when a student became pregnant and wanted to have an abortion.
Common Sense lost the will to live as the churches became businesses; and criminals received better treatment than their victims. Common Sense took a beating when you couldn't defend yourself from a burglar in your own home and the burglar could sue you for assault.
Common Sense finally gave up the will to live, after a woman failed to realise that a steaming cup of coffee was hot. She spilled a little in her lap, and was promptly awarded a huge settlement .
Common Sense was preceded in death, by his parents, Truth and Trust, his wife, Discretion, his daughter, Responsibility, his son, Reason.
He is survived by his 4 stepbrothers; I Know My Rights; I Want It Now; Someone Else Is To Blame; I'm A Victim.
Not many attended his funeral because so few realised he was gone.
If you still remember him, pass this on.
If not, join the majority and do nothing.
Cyber safety research may miss the mark
They will also will also "explore views on the consequences of these risks, and what technical and behavioural measures can be used by children, parents and teachers to help reduce them."
All well and good, and I'm very supportive of the Government for undertaking this important action, however I have my reservations about the nature of the final report and the person heading it up, Professor Donna Cross.
On the Bullying. No Way! website, Prof. Cross is quoted thus:
“...much good work has been done by researchers to assess the prevalence of the bullying problem but virtually no research has been conducted to investigate empirically what can be done to address this problem.”It seems she has found a way to get this important research funded by convincing the government that it is a cyber safety issue.
I disagree!
Bullying is a behavioural awareness and disciplinary issue that everyone can combat by working with perpetrators and victims, or potential victims, alike. It is a distinctly separate issue to cyber safety, which is a parental care and child educational issue requiring purely preventative measures and can not be combatted by working to rehabilitate perpetrators.
I fear that Prof Cross and her team at the Child Health Promotion Research Centre will lack the technological understanding and experience to complete this task in full. The question arises as to how this research grant was awarded to Professor Cross rather than any of the other tenders? If she was the best qualified for this work, then it is possibly a sad indictment on Australian commerce and academia.
Notably there is $2.3 million set aside for this research as well as a second project to develop a "repeatable survey instrument and methodology for data collection on the changes in behaviour of children, parents, teachers".
At the crux of the issue of cyber-safety is that parents, guradians and adults charged with relevant authority MUST take full responsibility in educating and supervising children's activity on any and every electronic media. The Bullying. No Way website (supported by Prof Cross' team at CHPRC) even tells us why:
“Many young people say that they wouldn’t report cyber bullying because most adults don’t know that they have a cyber life ... But parents have a moral, as well as a legal, responsibility to ensure that their children engage in safe and responsible behaviour – including online behaviour.”Precisley the point that Communications Minister, Stephen Conroy, and his team just don't seem to get, which is why they are insisting on imposing Internet Censorship via a secret filter on all ISP activity to ban black-listed sites.
Where is the control if parents don't know what their children are doing, who they are conversing with or what information they are unwittingly revealing about themselves, their location and their activities?
We wouldn't let our children walk the streets alone at night, yet there are many who allow their children to do just that in a cyber world. The risks and dangers are the same. The responsibility remains the same. Allowing a child to roam the streets alone is neglectful and it is a crime; so it should also be with cyber-media access. So it is, and so it shall remain. No cyber safety policy or Internet filter will change that.
Two fathers ... or even three
http://superbbluewren.livejournal.com/172586.html
You can also read my personal experience about parenting and what my daughter taught me about having three fathers.
If I were a rich man ...
The report by the World Institute for Development Economics Research of the United Nations University proclaims that the richest 2% of adults in the world own more than half of global household wealth. This excludes business, organisational and government wealth.
Further statistics demonstrate how the richest 1% of adults accounted for 40% of household assets in the year 2000, and that the richest 10% of adults accounted for 85% of the world total. In contrast, the bottom half of the world adult population owned a mere 1% share.
Whichever way you say it, there is no doubt that we have a massive skew in the distribution of assets and personal wealth across the globe. I'm going to keep the argument of lifestyle, quality of life, health and happiness out of this for moment, and make the assumption that each of these has a significant correlation to the relative income and assets of an individual. Money won't make you happy, but it certainly can take a few worries away from a starving family living in the dirt in a developing nation!
The report also found that just $2,200 of assets per adult placed a household in the top half of the world wealth distribution. To be among the richest 10% of adults in the world required just $61,000 in assets, and $500,000 qualified you for entry to the richest 1% along with 37 million others worldwide.

It was also noted that
many people in high-income countries have negative net worth and—somewhat paradoxically—are among the poorest people in the world in terms of household wealth
Facsinating reading - it really does put your own life into perspective!
Attitude, stupid!
... Ummm, No Dad ....
"What about Pakistanis in Australia?"
... Ahhh - nooo (waiting for it) ...
"Well, why are they running one for fucking Muslims?"
*sigh*
Because of exactly that kind of attitude, Dad!
Australia's core beliefs
Apparently average Australians have seven core beliefs, at least according to our moral-driven upstanding Prime Minister.
In a speech at the launch of The Conservative in September 2005, Mr Howard claimed that the following were our common beliefs:
We live in a very successful nation.
Tell that to hundreds of thousands who live below the poverty line, and especially our indigenous peoples who are battling to survive
We do not have much to be ashamed of
True ... except for our poor record on indigenous health & welfare, our cow-tailing to the USA, and our arrogance towards the Kyoto protocol
Australia was well-regarded around th world
see above comments
Individuals should be given a fair go if down on their luck but, once helped, should not expect continued community support
a fair comment unless it is advocating only helping people once and then writing them off for the rest of their life
Traditional institutions like the family were central but people with alternative views should not be persecuted
well ... should they be faced with discrimination too? And whose definition of family are we using anyway?
People should be very tolerant, but also believe in unity when facing a common threat
Stuff tolerance ... how about respect, acceptance and understanding ... and what if the threat is John Howard or the Liberal Party?
Society should be classless where a person's worth was determined by personal character and hard work, and not religion, race or social background
Newsflash!! How about if a person's worth was equalto all others and there were no determining factors at all?
Clearly, Mr Howard is now the spiritual leader of 20 million Australians, or at the very least considers himself to be a modern-day Moses in direct communication with a burning Golden Wattle tree!
Anything happen lately?
Firstly I have commenced, and am entirely enjoying, a new career in recruitment. What an amazing feeling to be doing a job that you love and helping so many people and businesses in the process.
Secondly I have been kept quite busy with parties, events and travel as well as reorganising the home office.
I am looking forward to getting my teeth back into the blogosphere. So much has been happening that it would take several long entries to try and catch up with everything. I won't even attempt it.
Having said that I wish to express my heartfelt sympathy and condolences to the family of Van Nguyen, who was murdered by the Singaporean Judiciary at 6am on the 2nd of December at Changi Prison. A very sad day for Australia, but also just another example of the horrific behaviour of which humanity is capable.
In addition, the passing into law of the industrial relations and the anti-terrorism changes, as well as the incomprehensible riots experienced in Sydney recently, and it is quite clear that the plug has been pulled, the toilet has flushed, and Australia is spiralling down the gurgler at an ever increasing rate.
Bring on the next election!
Answer my question Mr Birney
Not unexpectedly, the switchboard remained quite negative as the religious, the bigots, the ill-informed and the ignorant made all sorts of claims and accusations about the gay lobby and the best interests of the child.
I posed the following question to Matt Birney during his interview with harvey Deegan:
I am a divorced father of one child. I am also in a same-sex relationship with my partner of 7 years. In the event of some tragedy taking away the mother of my daughter, would Mr Birney and the Liberals object to my partner adopting my daughter or are they only objecting to my partner and I co-adopting a non-related child?
Mr Birney failed to directly answer the question, instead choosing to reiterate the argument that a child should have both a mother and a father. A tired argument that raises the question of whether it is better to be orphaned than to be raised without complementary gendered parents.
The crux of my question was that; in the hypothetical situation my daughter would logically be taken under my full time care. Why then, is it perfectly ok to have my partner in a co-parenting role but not be officially acknowledged as her legal guardian by way of adoption?
The fact is that current laws allow any person or two people, regardless of their relationship (eg: brother and sister, two friends, two grandmothers) or sexuality, the right to be considered for adoption. Even before the major law reforms of 2002 and before the ALP won government it was perfectly legal for single people (regardless of their sexuality) to adopt.
If it is SO important that a child has both a mother and a father then why won't the Liberals and their fellow moralisers campaign to remove the right of single people to adopt.
And while they are at it, why don't they try to legislate that widows and widowers must remarry if they are raising children.
It's not a perfect world, but in my absence I'd rather have my child loved by one good person, than remain alone as an orphan.
[+/-] show/hide this post
Bullying
Several important points stuck in my mind from this episode, not only because I was subjected to bullying for many years, but also because I am mindful of the risk that my own child may be bullied or that she could bully others. I don't say that lightly, after all no parent would expect their child to be a bully, but I remind myself that most bullies will go home after school and those hurtful characteristics may never be seen until the beginning of the next school day.
What incensed me most during this episode of Insight, was the presence of some teenagers (two boys in particular) who admitted, sometimes jovially, to bullying other kids.
TIM PAPANICOLAOU and RHYS PUCHAR (corrected spelling 16 Jan 2014) just didn't seem to get "it" - that bullying, no matter in the form, timeframe, context or intention, is just plain and simple bullying .. and it is WRONG! These kids (they have a long way to go before they are mature enough to be called adults) made comments like:
"Is not how they dress and act provoking the bullying? Because I see that a lot. Lots of...how girls dress, it can provoke bullying from her peers."
"Yeah, that sort of attention, they bring it on themselves sometimes. And you might not see it that way but like when they're walking around the way they do, it's pretty obvious to like everyone else at school."
As if that defence hasn't been used a thousand times in rape and assault cases! This is a neanderthal mentality and I expect it came from neanderthal parents.
These two morons also attempt to justify their perverse behaviour by claiming that it is only words and someone would have to be pretty thin-skinned for it to affect them badly.
"If they mean like nothing to you why would you take offence to what they say to you?"
"We went to one of the biggest schools in WA, and you get what you take and you give a bit out as well, you know."
The most shocking point of the forum (and when I cried) was an interview with a 10yo boy who had attempted suicide after months of torment. Prior to showing this clip the boys had made comments suggesting that it isn't as serious as people are claiming, and that no-one really gets to the stage of taking their own life:
"I've never seen a case of a kid actually going over the top to be like really depressed about it."
"Yeah, but then they've got to have emotional problems on another level as well. How can you be bullied to the extent..."
Blaming the victim again! It is their own fault if they react badly to taunts and abuse! Hello??? Anyone home?
Perhaps the crux of the matter was highlighted when a member of the audience asked the boys .. "but why should you bully in the first place?". Rhys answered with "I don't know. I think just for entertainment. I don't know, I think it's just a male thing, I just think it's a human thing actually."
What sad little beings these boys are, getting kicks from beating their chest and filling the air with their testosterone! And what do their parents think of this? I would have liked their parents interviewed to see whether the acts of bullying were promoted or supported by the family environment or just their peers at school.
Unfortunately the Insight program always runs out of time just as the participants are getting into the meaty heart of the matter. This episode was no different and there should have been more emphasis on dientifying the root causes of bullying.
The producers could have easily ignored the attendance of Akmal Saleh (Comedian) who admitted he had no idea of why he was there, having had no personal experience of bullying and simply suggested that victims could overcome bullying by "finding humour and not showing that you're upset".
If he intended to make a joke of the topic he almost succeeded, if not for the serious approach of other participants. Poor form Saleh .. and shame on the producers for inviting him. What on earth were they thinking?
XXX domain on hold
One would expect that any measure designed to protect Internet users from unwanted access to pornography would be a welcome initiative! By establishing a specific doamin for such material it would be very easy to block that area of the Internet - especially from children in the home, at schools or public institutions like libraries.
Despite the fact that the services would still be available to those who seek them, you would also expect that anti-porn campaigners, churches and "pro-family" advocates would support this move to protect families. Alas, No!
The god-botherers are at it again, and apparently they would prefer for pornography to be available around any corner than localised to a "red-light district" of the superhighway.
Apparently the organisation responsible for the management of domains, Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN), "has received almost 6000 letters and emails from individuals expressing concern about the impact of pornography on families and children".
Does it not occur to them that without this measure, and appropriate pressure to ensure that companies comply by migrating to the .xxx domain, families will have a greater risk of exposure?
Face the facts, people; just like alcohol, drugs and gambling, pornography is here to stay! We either learn to live with it as it is, or we take measures to minimise the harm it does to the vulnerable people in our society.
[+/-] show/hide this post
Theocracy Alert
On that basis I have reduced the level of the Early Warning System down to code YELLOW. If the situation remains status quo for the next couple of months I'll consider a further drop to sleepy GREEN.
More pertinent these days than the threat of theocracy is the rising threat of an Orwellian police state. While Australia is not yet going to be dragged down to the level of the UK's "shoot first" xenophobia, the fact that we are debating a national ID card with fingerprint, DNA or facial feature security systems is one that raises far more questions about rights versus security.
Lay off Douglas Wood!
Firstly, by the mixed and loosely factual accounts presented in the media, his release could, at best, be described as accidental good fortune. There appears to be little, if any, corroboration of specific intelligence that led to his "rescue". Any such intelligence was more related to the location of insurgents, who just happened to be holding Mr Wood. Their mission was to engage some suspects. Finding Mr Wood was a bonus.
Secondly, and probably more importantly, he was released by Iraqi forces, with the aid of coalition (presumably all US) military. Not a single Australian seems to have been involved in that manouvre. There seems to be no suggestion that Australians were even responsible for the intelligence that sparked the routine mission.
The third point is that, despite Mr Wood being a resident of the USA, it is the duty and reponsibility of the Commonwealth of Australia to protect and serve its citizens, no matter where they are or what their circumstances. Be it Schappelle Corby in an Indonesian prison, Douglas Wood in Iraq, or John Howard visiting the Whitehouse! There should be absolutely no expectation for any citizen to be faced with a bill for what is their inarguable right.
Before I conclude, I will point out, if you can't already see, the hypocrisy of demanding that Mr Wood not be able to profit from his traumatic experience while not a single complaint was heard about similar profiteering by victims like Stuart Diver. What is next? Will the emergency services be sending a bill to people rescued from armed hold-ups or if they fall over a cliff in a national park? Crazy stuff!
We have laws in Australia to prevent criminals from profiteering from their crimes, but Mr Wood is not a criminal, so why should we treat him like one? It is deplorable that we do!
I can only conclude that this is some form of bizarre tall-poppy syndrome. Douglas Wood is safe and seems to be physically none-the-worse for wear. Had he been brutalised, had a limb or two chopped off or suffering severe mental trauma, our sympathy would have overridden any whisper of reimbursing tax-payers. Perhaps it is because he and his family appear to have more than enough for themselves that we want a little for us.
Is it jealousy or greed that is fuelling this obscene call to diminsh this man's harrowing experience? Either way, it has to stop!
[+/-] show/hide this post
Priorities
Here's something that I found in my inbox recently - it pretty much sums up what I've been working with lately. I hope you get something out of it too.
A professor stood before his philosophy class and had some items in front of him. When the class began, wordlessly, he picked up a very large and empty mayonnaise jar and proceeded to fill it with golf balls.
He then asked the students if the jar was full. They agreed that it was.
The professor then picked up a box of pebbles and poured them into the jar. He shook the jar lightly. The pebbles rolled into the open areas between the golf balls. He then asked the students again if the jar was full. They agreed it was.
The professor next picked up a box of sand and poured it into the jar.
Of course, the sand filled up everything else. He asked once more if the jar was full. The students responded with a unanimous "yes."
The professor then produced two cups of coffee from under the table and poured the entire contents into the jar, effectively filling the empty space between the sand. The students laughed.
"Now," said the professor, as the laughter subsided, "I want you to recognize that this jar represents your life. The golf balls are the important things -- your God, your family, your children, your health, your friends, and your favorite passions -- things that if everything else was lost and only they remained, your life would still be full.
The pebbles are the other things that matter like your job, your house, and your car. The sand is everything else -- the small stuff. "If you put the sand into the jar first," he continued, "there is no room for the pebbles or the golf balls. The same goes for life. If you spend all your time and energy on the small stuff, you will never have room for the things that are important to you. Pay attention to the things that are critical to your happiness. Play with your children. Take time to get medical checkups. Take your partner out to dinner. Play another 18.
There will always be time to clean the house and fix the disposal.
Take care of the golf balls first -- the things that really matter. Set your priorities. The rest is just sand."
One of the students raised her hand and inquired what the coffee represented. The professor smiled. "I'm glad you asked. It just goes to show you that no matter how full your life may seem, there's always room for a couple of cups of coffee with a friend."
Libs bring out the dead
All the candidates for the WA State election are finalised and among the names we find a few surprises and a couple of laughs. I'll just highlight two of the Libs for now.
First off the rank has to be Graham Kierath returning as a candidate for Alfred Cove. Graham was a long-time Liberal MP and Minister for monumental failures, including Labour Relations and Health. He is unlikely to unseat sitting independant, Janet Woollard ... and we should all be thankful for that!
Graham seems to be in good company with the Libs also resurrecting failed Court (Dickie, not Sir Chuck) Minister, Roger Nicholls. He is well known for his poor management of Family and Community Services, among other notable events. I had a memorable clash with Roger in his early days as member for Mandurah and I find the man totally underwhelming. Roger is third on the ticket for South Metropolitan, which gives him little chance of taking a seat in the Council, so frankly I'm hoping he is merely trying to prop up the Libs rather than reinvent himself as a serious candidate.
[+/-] show/hide this post
Unravelling child pornography
A fellow blogger and Melbourne philospher has asked my view on child pornography. More specifically, he has questioned how it should be dealt with - zero tolerance or with a view to rehabilitate offenders?
I support both a zero tolerance approach with severe penalties for purveyors of such material, including gaol, and compulsory rehabilitation programs conducted by appropriate psychologists and sociologists for the consenting recipients (i.e. not those who accidentally download or receive such material).
That is the simple answer to the question, however the bigger issue is what constitutes child pornography. Most people do not ask themselves this question, and when they do there is often no suitably comprehensive answer. Even government agencies like the Australian Institute of Criminology (AIC) find it a difficult topic to define.
I'll explain further below, but don't hope to see any conclusions, except that I believe that the whole debate is frought with ambiguity, conjecture and the biased perception of the individual.
There would be very few that would argue against the typical public definition of child pornography. Something along the following lines:
"any material depicting a child or children engaging in a sexual act, posing in a sexual manner, or produced for sexual gratification of another person."
The problem with this is that there are several ambiguities to this approach. Such a definition is conditional upon a subjective opinion an what constitutes such things as "material", "child", "sexual", etc.
The Material.
Take for instance my baby photo, lovingly snapped by my parents as I lay naked in the bath at 6 months of age, my family jewels floating carefree in the shallow water for all to see. Pornography? Hardly! At least not to me or my family. But what about someone who found such material sexually arousing? To them it would have the air of pornogrphy just as a Bel Ami production would seem to me.
One person's innocent pic is another person's tool for sexual gratification.
Context is clearly important in this matter.
The Child.
No-one would doubt that a minor (less than the relevant legal age of consent) would be considered a "child" under the definition, but what of jurisdictions where an age of consent might differ from, say, 16 in Western Australia? What of jurisdictions in other nations where the age of consent may be 14 or 21? An enormous grey area lies between a mature young adult, sexually inquisitive youth and an innocent child.
It also begs the question of how we might deal with different scenarios such as:
- a 22yo male who is yet to reach puberty and may look like a pre-pubuscent 14yo.
- a 14yo female who is well developed and looks like a 22yo to any reasonable person.
Sexually explicit material containing either of these people would be defined as child pornography by some and legal porn by others. Now simply swap the gender of the two examples and, depending on the individual's perspective, the status of illegal porn or legal erotica may change.
Similarly, The different maturity and development of teenagers presents a problem in determining how the "reasonable person" might see a certain piece of material. The age (real and perceived) AND the gender of a child are major factors in determining whether material qualifies as criminal pornography or merely X-rated erotica.
The Sexual Behaviour.
Heralding back to the baby in the bath and comparing that with full sexual intercourse we can also see that the behaviour depicted in any material is also relevant to the context and thus the classification.
Take our pre-pubescent 22yo male (bearing in mind he looks 14) and in each of the following scenarios try and determine if it is considered criminal child pornography:
- use his naked photograph in a medical journal.
- in an explicit sexual act with a 16yo woman (i.e. legal age in WA).
- in an explicit sexual act with a 22yo woman
- in an explicit sexual act with a 48yo woman
Now, in each scenario, change the woman to a man. Does it make any difference to the classification? How about if we change him to a typically developed 22 year old who looks his age?
Finally for each of the above scenarios, change the main person to our 14yo well developed girl who looks 22yrs. Does the classification change depending on the gender and age of the people involved? Does it change if she is now 22years old instead of 14?
Throughout this exercise the majority of people will find at least one double standard due to age or gender. Clearly this highlights the ambiguous nature of sexuality and the law.
This issue is one of the most complex we have in our society today. Given that laws against child pornography are made to protect children from predation, more than stopping individual sexual gratification (no-one is legislating against imagination) perhaps the future for these people lies in technology.
In the future, with the increasing sophistication of computer graphics, we will need to determine whether computer generated material is just as offensive as the real thing. At this point it becomes a debate about an individual's unfulfilled desires, rather than protecting innocent children. At that point, where will we draw the line?
I previously mentioned the AIC site and it is well worth reading the various definitions to understand the complex nature of child pornography and the relevant laws.
On a final note, I admit to agreeing with Germaine Greer in her book, The Boy, in which she deals with the subject of the naked human form. Though she specifically wrote about young boys, I share the same enjoyment of both genders in art. Non-sexual nudity, in tasteful artistic representation, has been enjoyed by the masses throughout the ages. I do not consider such art to be pornographic, though others might. Each to his own.
Nudity can be sexualised by any individual for his/her own gratification, but such material must be judged by their context, not purely by the subject's age or gender. The context of someone caught with thousands of naked child pictures is similar, though less repulsive than someone caught with images and/or videos of children in sexual acts. The latter requires a harsher penalty than the first. Our laws need to reflect this as well as differentiate between the purveyors of child pornography and those who collect material for their personal use.
Just like drugs, the dealers are the real criminals preying on vulnerable people (children and the weak-minded), whereas some of the users often just need a helping hand to get them out of the situation.
[+/-] show/hide this post
The modern family
Bill Muehlenberg rises from murky christendom to denigrate women and homosexuals .. no surprises there!
Fortunately Bill and his ilk receive an upper-cut from a woman - in a same-sex relationship, no less! :-)
A great excerpt from a young girl's speech about her special adopted family gave me some joy that Australia hasn't been completely lost to the world of religious indoctrination and bigotry.
But perhaps the best argument is made by sociologist, Maggie Walter, with her simple conclusion "You don’t have a family; you be a family".
I'm waiting to see if my submission makes it into the list of published articles. Regardless I'll post it up here soon enough.
In the meantime, still on the topic of family, here's a little humour regarding the modern family ...
"Daddy, how was I born?"
Dad answered: "Ah, my son, I guess one day you will need to find out anyway! Well, you see your Mom and I first got together in a chat room on MSN. Then I set up a date via e-mail with your Mom and we met at a cyber-cafe. We sneaked into a secluded room, where your mother agreed to a download from my hard drive. As soon as I was ready to upload, we discovered that neither one of us had used a firewall, and since it was too late to hit the delete button,nine months later a blessed little Popup appeared and said ----- "You've Got Male!"
It's Maslow, stupid!
It takes a rare piece of journalism or opinion to make me stand back, reassess my own attitudes and finally to change my stance.
This piece in The Age today, does just that.
What Australian and US voters now crave
The Age - November 11, 2004
The left has failed to recognise society's need for a sense of social and moral order, writes Gregory Hywood.
But I'm going to take it further than the author does. It is more than just morality being sought, it is the wider umbrella of safety and security - the need to be protected.
It is clear to me now that we (the libertarian progressive left) have been going about the last few months (years even) with our heads stuck so far up our arse that we couldn't see what was really changing in Australia, let alone the rest of the world.
I'm not saying that we are wrong, just that we need to rethink the issues that are important to voters. I think Abraham Maslow might have the answer.
When an economy is doing well (as has the USA and Australia) basic needs, such as food, water, sleep etc, are mostly met and few want for much. Such is the first level of Maslow's "hierarchy of needs" - the physiological.
The next concern is that of safety. We desire the need for a secure home and a family. Refugees stuck in a detention centre are clear examples of those who desire this basic need. But middle Australia also, in its own way are being failed at this basic level, because national security and moral grounding are also tenets of safety.
When both physiological and safety needs are met, we tend to aim for love or inclusion - we need to feel we belong. That is part of the reason for creating a family. It is also why people joing sports clubs, community organisations and churches.
After that is met we focus on our esteem and we seek to improve this by the clothes we wear, the car we drive, the house we live in, the job we have. The luxuries in life that tell society "what and who we are". We give ourselves status.
Finally, if we can ever fulfil those four needs we can then seek 'self-actualisation'. We seek to improve ourselves, not by physical stuff but mentally and spiritually. Self-fulfilment, peace, knowledge etc.
It is becoming clear to me that the stereotypical "leftie" is predominantly coming from a higher level on Maslow's hierarchy. We are campaigning for how WE want the world to be by fighting for human rights and debating high-brow issues like stem-cell research and the war in Iraq. We are the Chardonnay set.
However, middle-Australia (as with the majority middle in the USA) are still scrambling to meet their needs for safety and belongingness. Quite often they are trying to aim for esteem needs (by purchasing plasma screens with surround sound) in the hope that it will fill the other hole in their life. But they are ahead of themselves. They turn to materialism because they cannot answer the need for safety and security for their family.
They are so hocked up (average debt is 140% of the average Australian's income compared with 50% two decades ago) that if interest rates rise by 1/4 of a point they will need to work an extra shift to pay for it.
These people, the majority of voters, do not care that Howard lies, as long as he keeps the economy safe. They've had enough of saving the trees and the rivers, they want someone to keep interest rates low and employment high. They have no need to understand the plight of refugees or the Sudanese because they are rightly concerned about their own plight. Charity must begin at home.
So how do we, the high and mighty lefties turn the focus from our pet projects (war, free trade agreements, old growth forests, medicare gold, gay rights, Telstra, ABC funding, etc) and towards the things that matter to THEM?
It's their sense of security, stupid!
Until all those millions of middle-Australia voters feel secure enough with their lot to comfortably move onto the esteem train, or even the self-actualization shuttle, we will be fighting a lost cause campaigning for the esoteric, the altruistic and the utopian.
The reason that we had the human rights boom of the 50's and 60's is precisely because the economy was sound and families were not under financial pressure. They had the time, the money and the desire to move past esteem-building and into promoting self-actualisation.
At the moment we are trying to pull down the upper-class in order to
haul the lower class up Maslow's ladder - over top of the middle
class, even! If instead we choose to help middle-Australia to move
beyond their safety-net concerns, they will undoubtedly turn around
and assist the lower class to move up.
How do we do it? I'm honestly not sure. But sitting in our ivory towers drinking Chardonnay and discussing the rights and wrongs of the world ain't cuttin' the mustard.
We need to be forming progressive economic policy that can be implemented step by step. E.g. While a Tobin tax is a great idea we need to realise that it isn't going to happen soon. However, income splitting is plausible and possible. An overhaul of the tax brackets to link them with CPI is a valid proposal. But these are just some of the ideas that need to be promoted and they require strong campaigns.
As much as I despise the religious right, I must admit that Family First seem to be on the right track. Their policies are in line with the strategy I've outlined above. They are off the blocks and racing ahead while we are left scratching our heads and wondering why everyone has shifted to the right.
They haven't! They've just voted for the people that are listening. We've stopped listening because we are spending too much time preaching about the things that DON'T matter (at the moment) to the average Australian. Us lefties are simply ahead of schedule in being too progressive for the issues that are not high priority and we've forgotten what really matters to the voters that count.
It reminds me of a human resource philosophy I learned many years ago ... a happy employee is an effective employee. If an employee is having trouble paying the mortgage, it will reflect in their work and they are less likely to be enthusiastic, effective or charitable to colleagues that may need help.
The same goes for voters - the Australian public. A happy Australian will be more enthusiastic, more effective in their work and home life and more likely to take an interest in current affairs, social issues and the plight of those less fortunate.
To that end, I'm making a big commitment to focus my energies on assisting the necessary reforms to shift mainstream Australia out of the safety mindset and into the esteem and self-actualisation phases. That can only be achieved by focussing my energy on domestic issues, especially pertaining to the economy.
I'm basing that strategy on the hope that once in these higher levels of Maslow's hierarchy, Australians will be content to support the greater causes in life. I could be wrong, but I'm hoping I'm right.
[+/-] show/hide this post
Troglodytes
It is infuriating to read articles and blogs and rantings from ignorant and ill-informed people. It is exponentially so, when the topic is so close to your own life that it becomes hard to not to take it personally.
Georg at Psephite has found such a moment and she is taking it personally. I'm with her side by side all the way when she exclaims "Enough is enough"!.
The reason? A post from Rose at Two Cents suggesting that it is "Not okay to be gay". Although Ms Rose does concede that
"homosexuals and lesbians ought not to be chastised for the way they are born"
she states without valid argument that
"while society must be 'accepting' of homosexuality, it ought not to be encouraging".
Rose then goes on the rampage over gay marriage, a certain Playschool episode, and ill effects of children with gay parents. Her unresearched and unsubstantiated conclusion is that
"teaching children that having parents of the same sex is okay will create an environment of unnecessary sexual confusion, and will represent a step in the wrong direction for Australian society".
The only evidence provided for her moral stand are two photographs - a picture of "Frank N Furter" (Rocky Horror Picture Show) and some kids in a schoolroom. Clearly Rose has some personal issues to deal with.
Fortunately Georg has filed a nice rebuttal that also "outs" her to the blogosphere as a lesbian mother and details the family relationship of her child's father and his same-sex partner.
And backing her up are many bloggers making their feelings known in the comments. It is noted that several comments have been deleted and no explanation given. The rant and the accompanying rebuttals are well worth a read. And be sure to leave a pleasant note for Rose and the crew at Two Cents just to let them know what you think about ignorant homophobes and heterosexist bloggers :-)
[+/-] show/hide this post
The end of a big election year
The Bush victory was easily predictable. Anyone claiming Kerry had a chance really had no understanding of the world we live in and the psyche of the US electorate. While I don't claim to be an expert, I do have my eyes open far enough to be able to read the signs. Objective analysis led me to predict Howard's win (though not his control of the Senate without the aid of Family First), the success of Family First, and Kerry's inability to win the people's vote.
In each of these events there were some key elements that should serve as a warning to future election campaigners.
- Voters are selfish
- Politics is unprincipled
- The media are not without bias
Three simple truths that seem to get lost in the excitement and banter of election fever.
Firstly, the majority of voters are loathe to think of anyone but themselves when marking the ballot paper. We live in a secular, individualistic society that has lost its community spirit. In the scramble to get to the top of the dung heap, we only manage to spread the manure further and are left smelling of crap. Gone are the days when we were all working for the common good and would lift a hand to help a stranger in need. Our national belief system lies in the divine trinity ... me, myself and I!
The irrational and purely selfish preference deals between some parties proves that politics is unprincipled. Even concrete policies are not as strong as they used to be as the ALP have shown by ditching long-held beliefs in favour of moving more towards the Coalition's views. It simply shows that such parties are opportunists rather than leaders with a principled vison for the future of a nation.
Undoubtedly, the gravest problem with our democratic elections is the influence of the media giants. There are very few balanced journalists left because they are increasingly being urged by their editors to provoke a response through the push of a particular opinion. To be fair, it is not that the media favours one party over another, it is merely that they make a commercial decision to not bite the hand that feeds them.
Politics and the work of government represents the majority of all news. To fall out of favour with the current government is a risk that no editor or producer is likely to take unless it is outweighed by an enormous ratings scoop that could take a government down. Hedging bets is not effective, so the media gamble on the outcome of the election to determine the party/candidate it needs to befriend.
Australia's electoral system, election advertising regulations and media ownership rules are some of the best in the world. We are able to safely state that our government is one of the most democratically elected because of compulsory voting and the preferential system.
Improvements to the system could be debated for years and without going into too much detail, some of my suggestions are:
- proportional representation in the lower houses
- optional preferential voting in both houses
- fixed terms of government to avoid election speculation
- eliminate Senate preference tickets
- eliminate distribution of "how-to-vote" propaganda at election booths
- election material to be approved by the AEC for factual validity
- a voter education campaign by the AEC
- revamp disclosure of political donations
I add the last point because I predict that the public will not be satisfactorily informed as to the source of funding for Family First. My expectation is that the vast majority (perhaps $750,000 or thereabouts) will remain undisclosed because it will be reported as minor donations from individuals. It is not hard to divvy a large donation up amongst a few fellow church-members in order to circumvent reporting regulations.
By no means am I suggesting that our system is bad, but it is open for improvement. There is a lot more that we can do for democracy (citizen initiated referenda and restructuring of the federal system to reduce the tiers of government are examples) but these suggestions are a good start.
The USA is not so lucky. They need a complete overhaul to remove the electoral college, reduce the unbreakable power of the two-party system, provide fairer access for voter registration, homogenise ballot mechanisms and eliminate the campaign funding loopholes.
[+/-] show/hide this post